When you think of Jimmy Carter, it’s almost impossible not to picture the peanut farmer from Georgia with a disarming smile, a Bible in hand, and a heart set on service. As the 39th president of the United States, Carter’s legacy is as complex as it is fascinating. His life and presidency present a tapestry woven with triumphs, stumbles, and steadfast faith.

The Man of Faith

Let’s start with what we, as Christians, can unequivocally respect: Jimmy Carter’s faith. The man was a devout Christian who taught Sunday School well into his 90s. He didn’t just talk the talk; he walked the walk, often emphasizing humility, forgiveness, and compassion. Carter’s post-presidency years, spent building homes with Habitat for Humanity, stand as a testament to his servant’s heart.

Carter reminded the nation that public service could be an expression of faith. He was not ashamed to share his love for Christ, and his policies often reflected his moral convictions. Even if we might not agree with all his decisions, his commitment to morality and integrity is undeniable. He was—and is—a role model for Christians in public life.

The Political Carter: Hits and Misses

Now, while Carter the man shines, Carter the president had a mixed record. Let’s break it down.

Foreign Policy: A Mixed Bag

On the world stage, Carter’s presidency was a whirlwind of highs and lows. The Camp David Accords, brokered between Israel and Egypt, were a diplomatic triumph. It was a rare win in the volatile Middle East, and Carter’s ability to bring together two long-standing adversaries showed his dedication to peace. Conservatives who value stability in the region can give him credit for this accomplishment.

But then there was the Iran Hostage Crisis, a black eye on his administration. Carter’s inability to secure the release of 52 American hostages for 444 days damaged the nation’s morale and made the U.S. appear weak on the global stage. The botched rescue mission only deepened the sense of failure. His approach lacked the decisive strength we often look for in a leader defending American interests.

Domestic Policy: A Struggle

Domestically, Carter’s presidency struggled to find its footing. Inflation soared, unemployment spiked, and the infamous gas lines became symbols of economic malaise. Conservatives rightly critique his inability to rein in government overreach and address these issues with pro-growth policies. His support for expanding federal programs didn’t sit well with those of us who believe smaller government leads to greater freedom and prosperity.

However, Carter’s emphasis on energy independence—a cause he championed long before it was fashionable—deserves some recognition. His push for renewable energy and conservation wasn’t popular in his day but showed foresight. Conservatives can appreciate the principle of stewardship, even if we differ on methods.

The Post-Presidency Saint

Where Carter truly shined was in his post-presidency years. He redefined what it means to be an ex-president. His work with Habitat for Humanity, efforts to fight disease in developing nations, and promotion of free elections worldwide reflected his commitment to service. He didn’t fade into the background; he rolled up his sleeves and got to work. This humility and perseverance are qualities that Christians and conservatives alike should admire.

A Legacy of Integrity and Humility

Jimmy Carter’s legacy is not one of flashy speeches or partisan battles. Instead, it’s a legacy of quiet faith and a genuine desire to serve. While his presidency had its faults—some of them significant—it’s clear that his heart was always in the right place. Carter reminds us that leaders, like all of us, are imperfect vessels trying to do their best.

As an independent Christian conservative, I find myself both admiring and critiquing Carter. I admire his faith, humility, and post-presidency service. I critique his economic policies and his perceived weakness on the global stage. But above all, I respect him as a man who lived out his Christian principles in public life, even when it wasn’t easy or popular.

Jimmy Carter’s life reminds us of the biblical truth found in 2 Corinthians 12:9: “My grace is sufficient for thee: for my strength is made perfect in weakness.” For all his flaws and failures, Carter’s strength was his faith, and for that, he has left a legacy worth reflecting on.